Should I buy individual stocks or mutual funds?

We're all getting back to basics like friends, family and frugality. In the market, old hands are reconsidering their basic assumptions, and newer investors wonder whether anything they've learned thus far still holds.Cautious investors love companies that send profits to shareholders. Companies that pay dividends tend to be in more-stable sectors, such as consumer staples or utilities, and they pay investors through good market times and bad. And with so many of us suspicious about Wall Street, dividends are real money you can trust more than forecasts or projections.

These days, some experts say single stocks are simply too risky for most investors. The real answer depends on how much time you have. If you go with stocks, you're going to need at least a dozen and probably more. A variety keeps you diversified, so that problems in one company or sector won't wipe you out. You also need the time to understand and track those stocks; if you don't, you're speculating, not investing.Mutual funds let investors pool their resources so that a professional money manager can invest for them. The problem here is that the returns posted by most mutual fund managers trail the market, partly because of their fees. (Read "Are fund managers worth their pay?" for more.)

You also get a tax bill as they buy and sell and, hopefully, collect capital gains.
A solution is to go with index funds that invest in a broad basket of stocks such as the S&P 500 Index ($INX). The fees are lower, and you get the diversification you need. Plus the stocks are traded less often, so the tax burden is usually lower.

What's the difference between a mutual fund and an ETF?

With a mutual fund, you give your money to a fund company, which then invests it in such things as stocks or bonds. The fund's value is calculated once a day, after the markets have closed. An ETF, or exchange-traded fund, is a basket of stocks, bonds or commodities that usually follows an index and that you can buy and sell throughout the day, just like a stock. ETFs typically have lower expenses and fees, but, as with a stock, you have to pay a commission to buy them. Because you control sales, you have more control over when you'll get a tax bill for taking profits.

Mutual Funds: What You Need to Know

By TARA SIEGEL BERNARD

Mutual funds are the building blocks of your investment portfolio.
Your Money Guides

There are thousands of funds to choose from, yet most investors really don’t need more than four or five funds. Sifting through all of the choices can be rather daunting.

But it needn’t be. Here is a look at the essentials, along with guidelines on what to look for when purchasing a fund. Once you are done, you should have a better grasp on how to choose the investments you need to build a diversified portfolio, whether it’s for your child’s college fund or retirement savings.

For most investors, mutual funds -- which are a collection of stocks, bonds or other investments -- are the simplest and least expensive way to access wide swaths of the stock and bond markets.

Exchange-traded funds, which are essentially mutual funds that you can trade just like a stock, are also useful in certain circumstances, which you can read more about here.

The Mechanics
First, let’s take a quick look at how mutual funds work: When you choose a fund, you send the fund company money, which is pooled with other investors’ money. It’s all used to buy dozens upon dozens of stocks, bonds, or other investments. That’s part of the beauty of mutual funds -- most investors could not achieve that level of diversification on their own. (Investors do not actually own the underlying stocks or bonds; instead, they own a piece of the fund itself, in the form of shares. As the value of the underlying investments rises and falls, so does the value of your fund shares).

But how a fund manager chooses what to buy is what differentiates one fund from another. Some funds are actively managed, which means that a portfolio manager looks for stocks, bonds or other investments that will fit the fund’s overall objective. The goal for all active managers is to outperform certain benchmarks, like the Standard & Poor’s 500 index, which tracks 500 large domestic companies. As part of the stock-picking process, fund managers often travel to meet individual companies and essentially kick the tires: they visit factories, talk with customers, meet with management, and analyze financial statements. All of that costs money, of course, which is one of the main reasons actively managed funds are more expensive then the alternative: index funds.

Index funds simply replicate the performance of various indexes like the Standard & Poor’s 500. Meanwhile, because indexes do not change their underlying components very often, they do not need to make a lot of trades, which also increases costs. A lot of trading may also give rise to taxable capital gains, which must be distributed to fund shareholders along with the tax liability.

For all of these reasons, index funds cost only a fraction of actively managed funds. And lower costs are why index funds tend to outperform their actively managed counterparts over the long term. To beat index-tracking funds, fund managers have to add more to returns than the cost of running the fund. It is hard to do.

How to Evaluate a Fund
First, you need to figure out what type — or style — of fund you need, which is based on your investment goals, time horizon, tolerance for risk, among other factors. After deciding what types of funds you need — like an international stock fund or a fund of small companies — you will want to evaluate the funds in each category using the following criteria:

COSTS: First, find out if there are any suitable index funds — they have the lowest costs and typically beat their actively managed counterparts over time. The average active mutual fund charges about 1.4 percent of your investment each year — this charge is known as a fund’s expense ratio — while the average index fund costs 0.80 percent. Many funds are available for much less. The Vanguard Total Stock Market Fund, for instance, provides exposure to the entire market for only 0.07 percent.

Pay close attention to other fees. You want to avoid funds that charge loads, which are sales charges levied when you buy or sell a fund. The charge is paid to the financial broker selling the fund. Load funds are sold in different share classes, which each have a unique fee structure. You can avoid loads altogether by buying directly from fund companies like Vanguard, T. Rowe Price, Fidelity and others.

COMPANY: Do business with companies that have long track records. The same goes for portfolio managers. Find out how long they have been running the fund, and what they have done in the past. Web sites like Morningstar.com track this type of information.

PERFORMANCE: Don’t put too much weight on fund performance. Often, this year’s star funds are next year’s worst performers. Check the fund’s performance over three-, five- and 10-year periods. If the fund is actively managed, compare how the fund has performed versus its benchmark, especially during market downturns. Be sure to stack it alongside its peers, or funds of the same style, too. Choose a fund with relatively consistent returns.